


















Fifteen brands, their own numbers
Compared, in plain numbers
As printed on each brand's own product page on October 11, 2026. Ours is one row, not the winner.
| Brand | Ingredients | Net wt | Price | Per oz | Subscriber per oz | Try window |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ancestral Cosmetics | 4 | 60 ml (2 oz), by volume | €26.00 | €13.00 | €11.70 (10% off, plan data) | not stated |
| Based Supplies | 4, image only (Oct 9) | 2 oz | $30.00, sold out | $15.00 | no subscription found | 30 days |
| Craft Tallow ours | 5 | 2 oz (56 g) | $34.00 | $17.00 | $15.30 renewals, $12.75 first delivery | 60 days |
| Gentle Tallow Co. | 2 | 2 oz | $20.00 | $10.00 | $9.00 (10% off, plan data) | not stated, refunds case by case |
| Hearth & Homestead | 2 | 1.3 oz | $26.97 | $20.75 | $18.67 (10% off, plan data) | 30 days, unopened, store credit |
| Primally Pure | 6 (Oct 9) | 2 oz (Oct 9) | $34.00 (Oct 9) | $17.00 (Oct 9) | 0% off (plan data) | returns within 60 days |
| Toups and Co | 2 | 2 oz | $32.00 | $16.00 | $14.40 (10% off) | 30 days |
| Vintage Tradition | 2 | 2 fl oz (59 ml) | $22.95 | $11.48 per fl oz | no subscription | one month |
Per oz is price divided by net weight. Subscriber per oz is the same arithmetic on the brand's own printed or plan subscription price; ours is 10% off renewals and 25% off the first delivery. Vintage Tradition, Ancestral Cosmetics and Tallow Twins print a volume, so their figures are not strictly comparable. Up to half of a whipped jar can be air.All fifteen brands, every column
Before you buy
Beef fat on my face?
Suet rendered gently has almost none. Bare Silk is unscented. The other four smell of their botanicals.
A pea-sized amount on damp skin finishes matte. Greasy means you used too much.
Tallow scores low to moderate on comedogenic scales. Patch test if you are blemish-prone.
“With bakuchiol” on a label can mean a trace. Velvet’s is a true 1%, stated on the page, twice the dose in the published trial.

From our kitchen counter to yours.
We blend in small batches in the Mountain West on a base of 100% Montana suet, and we check each jar before it ships from our home in Cottonwood Heights, Utah.
Brian and AspenThe Craft Tallow standard
-
Non-toxic
No parabens, phthalates, synthetic fragrance, or dyes. Never List →
-
Hormone supportive
Formulated without classes flagged as endocrine disruptors. Never List →
-
Short labels
Five to ten ingredients a jar, every one named. Ingredients →
-
Montana suet
Grass-fed and grass-finished. Slow-rendered, never bleached. Suet, not trim →
-
Small batches
Blended in the Mountain West. Shipped from Cottonwood Heights, Utah. About →
-
60-Day Skin Test
Sixty days with any jar. If your skin disagrees, we refund the purchase, original shipping excluded. The rules →