We haven't tested Evil Goods' jars against ours in a lab. Every fact about them below came off their live pages on October 8, 2026, and our own prices are from that day too. Both brands put manuka honey in a tallow jar. Evil Goods whips theirs into a light moisturizer in five scents, and we pour ours dense and sell it by weight.
The fair match for theirs is Honey Glow ($42), our manuka jar. If you'd rather start plain, Bare Silk ($34) is five ingredients, and the Unscented carries no essential oils.
Two manuka jars: what does each brand sell?
Evil Goods sells its manuka jar as the Whipped Tallow and Manuka Honey Moisturizer. On October 8, 2026, it came Unscented or in four scents, all at $34.99, and their home page showed it marked down from $49.99. The product page's text doesn't show a size. Its summary line for search engines calls it a 4 oz jar, and "Made in USA" runs across their pages. None of the pages I read put the jar on a store shelf, though their refund policy sends marketplace orders through that marketplace's own returns.
We make five balms, each built for one job and poured dense into a 2 oz (56 g) jar. There's no water in any recipe. Honey Glow is the dry-skin jar, so it's the one carrying manuka. Bare Silk is our plain, everyday one. The other three each have their own job, from redness-prone skin in the evening to the look of scars.
How do the two manuka jars compare?
Here's what their pages showed on October 8, 2026, beside Honey Glow Classic as our page showed it that day.
| Read Oct 8, 2026 | Evil Goods Whipped Tallow & Manuka Honey Moisturizer, Unscented | Craft Honey Glow Classic |
|---|---|---|
| Size as stated | 4 oz, in the page's search summary | 2 oz (56 g) |
| Weight or volume | Not stated | Net weight |
| One-time price | $34.99, down from $49.99 | $42 |
| Per ounce | About $8.75, as described | $21.00 by weight |
| Ingredients named | Four or five, no full list | 8 |
| Manuka honey | In the name, and in some variations per their FAQ | Oil-soluble extract |
| Fat as named | Grass-fed, grass-finished beef tallow | Grass-fed 100% suet tallow |
| Essential oils | None named | None |
| Texture | Whipped | Poured dense |
| Guarantee | 30 days, 20% restocking fee on items that arrived as ordered | 60-Day Skin Test |
| Shipping | Free within the US | Free from $35, always free on a subscription |
I couldn't find one full ingredient list for their Unscented jar. One line on the page names grass-fed grass-finished tallow, manuka honey, cold-pressed olive oil and organic vitamin E, and stops there. Their FAQ names four as well. It puts pot marigold extract where the honey was and says manuka goes into some variations, without naming which. Another block on the page shows all five together. Honey Glow lists eight. Neither page lists water or a wax, and neither names an essential oil.
On price, theirs is the bigger buy: at $34.99 for a jar described as 4 oz, it works out near $8.75 an ounce. Honey Glow is $21.00 an ounce by weight. On a balm, a plain oz means weight, since the federal rule for cosmetic labels, 21 CFR 701.13, states a semisolid in avoirdupois ounces and keeps fluid ounces for liquids. Their page prints no grams, though, so I'm reading that 4 oz as a description for now.
Whipped or poured: does the air matter?
Their page calls the moisturizer "Whipped smooth and fast-absorbing," which is the feel whipping is for. Up to half of a whipped jar can be air. We start where whipped ends up, so Honey Glow's poured dense and every gram on its label is balm.
Here's the fair part. Air only costs you grams when a jar's sold by volume, so if their 4 oz is a weight, you're buying 4 oz of balm however much air rides along. The whipping changes the feel and the room it fills. Their Unscented jar is one of the eight on order for our bench, and its weight and density land on tallow balms bought and weighed in part two. Until the scale reads it, I won't claim a number for their jar.
What does Evil Goods do well?
I'd give them two things plainly, and the first is how much jar you get for the money. A jar described as 4 oz for $34.99 is generous. Every scent costs the same, and subscribe and save brought it down to $29.99 on the product page. The page carried more than 1,500 reviews.
The second is a subscription that bends, with deliveries anywhere from every month to every four months. The page offers "Change Scents Anytime" beside "Cancel Anytime," and if you like a new scent each season, that's a thoughtful setup.
Where do the two jars part ways?
The first difference is the fat itself, and how each of us buys it. Their product page says grass-fed, grass-finished beef tallow, and their About page credits "regenerative American farms" for it, though the product page doesn't use the word suet. We source 100% suet, the dense fat from around the kidneys, from grass-fed and grass-finished cattle on Montana family ranches, bought direct. We buy the fat. We do not run the ranch. Our Montana render partner renders it, and the balms are blended in small batches in the Mountain West.
The second is the honey's form. Honey Glow carries an oil-soluble manuka honey extract, so the honey sits in the fat and there's no water in the recipe. The research set the doses, and manuka honey in skincare goes deeper on the honey itself.
The third is the guarantee. Their product page promises a refund if your skin doesn't look or feel better in 30 days. Their refund policy counts those days from when the order arrives, and it takes a 20% restocking fee on items that arrived as ordered. Ours is the 60-Day Skin Test. That's sixty days with any jar, and if your skin disagrees, we refund it.
Who should buy which?
Buy theirs if you like a light, whipped feel and want the most jar for your money. Honey Glow is the jar I'd hand a reader who wants manuka in a dense balm sold by weight, with sixty days to decide. It's cosmetic care, not a treatment, and your provider's plan comes first. If you'd rather start with nothing added, Bare Silk Unscented carries no essential oils, and it's our everyday jar for face and body.
Start with Bare Silk ($34), five ingredients and sixty days to disagree.
Questions we hear
Is Evil Goods good?
We haven't tested their jar against ours in a lab, so I can't grade it for your skin. Their page showed more than 1,500 reviews on October 8, 2026. It promised a refund if your skin didn't look or feel better in 30 days, and their refund policy takes a 20% restocking fee on items that arrived as ordered. If a light, whipped jar with honey suits you, it's worth a look.
Is Evil Goods tallow worth it?
On price per ounce, it's hard to beat: $34.99 one time or $29.99 on subscription on October 8, 2026. The page's summary line called it 4 oz, about $8.75 an ounce. Their Unscented jar is on order for our bench, and its grams land on our bench page in part two.
Evil Goods vs Craft Tallow, which is better for the face?
I can't call that one, since we haven't put the two jars on the same face. Bare Silk ($34) is our everyday face jar, with no essential oils in the Unscented, and Honey Glow ($42) is the one for dry skin. For the look of fine lines, Velvet Face Renewal ($89) is the jar we built. Your skin gets the last word.
How much balm is in an Evil Goods jar by weight?
The product page text prints no weight, and the summary line it gives search engines calls it a 4 oz jar, with no fl and no grams. A plain ounce on a balm is a weight under the federal labeling rule, but a summary line isn't a label. Their Unscented jar is on order for our bench. Its weight lands on our bench page in part two, and there's no number from us until then.
Does Evil Goods use essential oils?
Their product page names none, and its FAQ says their products are free from artificial fragrances. Any scent, it adds, comes from the ingredients themselves. On October 8, 2026, the moisturizer came Unscented or as Lavender, Citrus, Sandalwood or Santal Vanilla, with no full list for each scent. On our side, Bare Silk Unscented and Honey Glow Classic don't carry any.
Go deeper
If Based Supplies is the other jar on your list, Evil Goods vs Based Supplies sets the two side by side, with Honey Glow as a third jar. Tallow and honey balm: does it work reads five honey jars' labels beside ours. Whipped tallow 101 shows what whipping does to the fat, and the tallow balm comparison page lines up the brands we've read. If tallow on skin is new to you, start with the beef tallow for skin guide.
Sources
- Evil Goods, the brand's own website (2026). Whipped Tallow & Manuka Honey Moisturizer, with its prices and FAQ, read October 8, 2026. evilgoods.com.
- Evil Goods, the brand's own website (2026). Home page, with the jar marked down from $49.99, read October 8, 2026. evilgoods.com.
- Evil Goods, the brand's own website (2026). About Us, on their tallow and where it comes from, read October 8, 2026. evilgoods.com.
- Evil Goods, the brand's own website (2026). Refund policy, a 30-day window and a 20% restocking fee, read October 8, 2026. evilgoods.com.
- US Food and Drug Administration (2026). Code of Federal Regulations, title 21, section 701.13: declaration of net quantity of contents. eCFR.
- Craft Tallow, our own Journal (2026). Tallow balms bought and weighed: eight jars on the bench, part one. crafttallow.com.
Brian is the founder of Craft Tallow, a small-batch tallow skincare line shipped from Cottonwood Heights, Utah, built on 100% grass-fed suet. Questions? Reply to any email from us; it lands with him.