We haven't tested Eat My Face's creams against our balms in a lab, and every fact about them here came off their live pages on October 8, 2026. Their tallow moisturizers sell for $24.99 each. Their home page says Google's AI Overview ranks them first for beef tallow for face.
Their Original moisturizer was sold out that day, and their home page named the Baby & Momma Cream "the fragrance-free stand-in" for it. That's the tin I've set beside Bare Silk ($34), our five-ingredient jar. Its Unscented edition carries no essential oils, and I read its price on the same day as theirs.
What does each brand sell?
Their home page calls the shop founder-run in California, and the Original's page says it's made in small batches in Eugene, Oregon. As of October 8, 2026, the Original moisturizer and the Baby & Momma Cream each came in a 4 oz metal tin, and a Night Cream with lavender and chamomile sold at the same price. Past the moisturizers, the shop sells tallow soap bars, an after-sun balm, an SPF 30 mineral sunscreen in a 4 oz tube, and bundles that pair them.
Ours is a shorter shelf: five balms, each poured dense into a 2 oz (56 g) jar and sold by weight. Bare Silk's the everyday jar. Honey Glow ($42) is for dry skin, and Moonlight Calm ($69) for redness-prone skin. Velvet Face Renewal ($89) takes on the look of fine lines, and Recovery Balm ($74) is for the look of scars and stretch marks. The Craft Tallow Kit ($110, on pre-order with about a three-week ship window) lets you blend at home. We don't make soap or sunscreen. Our balms carry no SPF, and tallow doesn't screen UV, as tallow and SPF explains.
How does the fragrance-free tin compare with Bare Silk?
| Read Oct 8, 2026 | Eat My Face Baby & Momma Cream | Craft Bare Silk Unscented |
|---|---|---|
| Size as printed | 4 oz metal tin | 2 oz (56 g) |
| Net weight printed | None on the page | 56 g |
| Price | $24.99 | $34 |
| Per ounce | About $6.25 on the printed 4 oz | $17.00 by weight |
| Ingredients | 9 | 5 |
| Essential oils | None | None |
| Water | None | None |
| Fat named | Grass-fed beef tallow | Suet, grass-fed and grass-finished |
| Texture words | Rich tallow texture | Poured dense |
| Guarantee | 180-Day Guarantee | 60-Day Skin Test |
Their list runs nine items: grass-fed beef tallow, shea butter, cocoa butter, arrowroot powder, sea buckthorn oil, vitamin E, jojoba oil, coconut oil, cetyl alcohol. Bare Silk Unscented lists five: grass-fed suet tallow, meadowfoam seed oil, organic jojoba oil, vitamin E, organic arrowroot. There's plenty of overlap, since four of our five turn up on theirs.
The per-ounce row needs care, because their page gives 4 oz as the size of the tin and prints no net weight for the cream inside. Under the federal rule for cosmetic labels, 21 CFR 701.13, a semisolid cosmetic's net quantity goes by weight, in avoirdupois ounces. Bare Silk's label reads 2 oz (56 g). If their 4 oz is the cream's weight, their tin costs well under half of what ours does per ounce. Their tin isn't among the eight jars on order for tallow balms bought and weighed, our bench page, so I've no measured weight for it.
What does Eat My Face do well?
Two things stand out on their pages, and the first is the price for the size. Each moisturizer I read was $24.99, and on the printed 4 oz that's about $6.25 an ounce, against our $17.00 by weight. Free US shipping starts at $30. Their home page also showed 4.8 out of 5 from more than 5,000 reviews.
The second is their plain answers. Their FAQ says a tin that melts in hot shipping isn't spoiled, and it firms back up after about an hour in the fridge. It puts an opened tin at 6 to 12 months in daily use. When the Original ran out, their home page said so and pointed shoppers to the fragrance-free tin, which is good shopkeeping.
Where do we differ?
The first difference is the fat: their pages name grass-fed beef tallow. Their story page says it's gently rendered, "never bleached, never deodorized." We source 100% suet, the dense fat from around the kidneys, from grass-fed and grass-finished cattle on Montana family ranches, bought direct. We buy the fat. We do not run the ranch. Our Montana render partner renders it, and the balms are blended in small batches in the Mountain West. Jars are checked and shipped from Cottonwood Heights, Utah. Suet, not trim explains how that fat differs from trim, the scraps left from cutting.
The second difference is how the recipes split. On the lists I read, their three moisturizers share one nine-ingredient base, which the Original tops with beeswax and vanilla. The Night Cream adds chamomile oil and lavender oil. Ours all start from one suet and go five ways, one job to a jar. Bare Silk is the plain jar. The research set the doses in the other four, and Velvet Face Renewal carries 1.5% oil-soluble vitamin C (tetrahexyldecyl ascorbate) and a true 1% bakuchiol, twice the 0.5% in the published head-to-head trial against retinol. The Kit's a further difference, since with it you do the blending.
The guarantee is where they're ahead. Their product pages show a 180-Day Guarantee, three times the length of our sixty days. Their refund and shipping policy pages wouldn't load for me on October 8, 2026, so I can't give their terms, and I've used nothing from either. Ours is the 60-Day Skin Test: sixty days with any jar, and if your skin disagrees, we refund it. Shipping's free in the US from $35, and subscribers always ship free. Both shops price in US dollars, and their FAQ says they ship within the US only for now.
Who should buy which?
Buy theirs if you want a big tin at a low price with a long guarantee behind it. Bare Silk is a third jar to weigh, for a reader who wants five ingredients sold by weight and sixty days to decide. For the look of fine lines, the jar we built is Velvet Face Renewal ($89). For baby skin and pregnancy, it's Bare Silk Unscented. It's cosmetic care, not a treatment, so your provider's plan comes first, and for a baby that's the pediatrician.
Start with Bare Silk ($34), five ingredients and sixty days to disagree.
Questions we hear
Is Eat My Face good?
We haven't tested Eat My Face's creams against ours in a lab, so I can't grade one on your skin. On October 8, 2026, the site carried 4.8 out of 5 from more than 5,000 reviews, and the Baby & Momma Cream listed nine ingredients with no fragrance added. If that list suits your skin, it's a fair tin to try.
Is Eat My Face tallow worth it?
On October 8, 2026, each Eat My Face moisturizer I read was $24.99, and two were sold as 4 oz tins. That's about $6.25 an ounce on the printed size. Their pages print no net weight, so I can't give a price per gram. Bare Silk is $34 for 56 g, or $17.00 an ounce by weight, so on price for size theirs is well ahead.
Eat My Face vs Craft Tallow, which is better for the face?
Neither brand's page settles that, and we haven't tried the two side by side on anyone's face. Their Original page points it at the face and neck. Bare Silk ($34) is our everyday face jar, with no essential oils in the Unscented. For the look of fine lines, Velvet Face Renewal ($89) is the jar we built, and it goes on morning and night.
How much balm is in an Eat My Face tin by weight?
Eat My Face's pages don't say. The Original and Baby & Momma pages give the container as a 4 oz metal tin, and neither prints a net weight in ounces or grams. I've read their web pages, not a tin's label. Their tin isn't among the eight jars on order for our bench page, so I've no measured weight to give you. Bare Silk's label prints a net weight of 2 oz (56 g).
Does Eat My Face use essential oils?
Not in the Baby & Momma Cream, whose page says no fragrance is added and no essential oils. As of October 8, 2026, the Original listed vanilla and no essential oil. The Night Cream's list ends with chamomile oil and lavender oil, and their FAQ says most of the line is lightly scented. Bare Silk Unscented doesn't carry an essential oil, and its Lavender Edition does.
Go deeper
Best tallow balm runs eight brands through the same checks, and the tallow balm comparison page sets twelve side by side. How to read a tallow label puts net weight among its six checks. If tallow on skin is new to you, the beef tallow for skin guide is where I'd start.
Sources
- Eat My Face, the brand's own website (2026). Beef Tallow Baby & Momma Cream, its 4 oz tin and nine ingredients, read October 8, 2026. eatmyface.co.
- Eat My Face, the brand's own website (2026). Beef Tallow Moisturizer, Original, sold out, with the 180-Day Guarantee, read October 8, 2026. eatmyface.co.
- Eat My Face, the brand's own website (2026). Beef Tallow Night Cream with lavender and chamomile, both oils listed, read October 8, 2026. eatmyface.co.
- Eat My Face, the brand's own website (2026). Home page, with the product range and the site's review count, read October 8, 2026. eatmyface.co.
- Eat My Face, the brand's own website (2026). Our Story, on how the brand describes its tallow, read October 8, 2026. eatmyface.co.
- Eat My Face, the brand's own website (2026). FAQ, on melting in hot shipping and on shelf life, read October 8, 2026. eatmyface.co.
- US Food and Drug Administration (2026). Code of Federal Regulations, title 21, section 701.13: declaration of net quantity of contents. eCFR.
- Craft Tallow, our own Journal (2026). Tallow balms bought and weighed: eight jars on the bench, part one. crafttallow.com.
Brian is the founder of Craft Tallow, a small-batch tallow skincare line shipped from Cottonwood Heights, Utah, built on 100% grass-fed suet. Questions? Reply to any email from us; it lands with him.